Oh, mirror in the sky, what is love? Can the child within my heart rise above? Can I sail through the changing ocean tides? Can I handle the seasons of my life? -Fleetwood Mac –
My teen went to high school today but sheâs not a high school student. Instead sheâs touring a local high school in an activity called âshadow day.â Sheâll attend classes and, hopefully, get an idea of what itâs like to be a student there.
Much preparation went into this shadow day. She had to secure a coveted spot; get tested for Covid no more than 72 hours in advance; and, of course, select the right outfit. Of course, I did not prepare myself and so, I was not prepared for the nausea that rose in me the few seconds it took for her to turn from me, bounce up the steps and dart through the frosted glass doors into another world.
We learn the phrase âobject permanenceâ when we first become interested in a baby. People whose job it is to know, explain that babies cry when mother goes away because babies just donât understand the concept of âobject permanence.â A thing can go away and still exist. But, they reassure us, once baby sees that father leaves and then comes back, baby wonât cry or at least wonât cry so much. And there is more good news. We can help baby understand through games like peek-a-boo. âSeeâ, we say, âhereâs my face, now itâs behind my hand. Iâm still here!â
While standing with the other parents on the sidewalk, looking at the watercolor shapes and figures as they shifted behind the frosted glass doors, I wondered, âDo babies feel nauseous during their first peek-a-boo experience?â Maybe, they cry because of the nausea. I felt like crying, too.
Really, my daughter practices leaving all the time. She is getting pretty good at leaving. She is the captain of her ship. I need lots of practice standing on the shore. I try to help. âLook out,â I shout into the wind, âI crashed there once before!â If you have never shouted into the wind, try it. Your words donât get very far. I am learning to live with the nauseous feeling.
But really, she has been practicing leaving for a long time, for like forever. Babies disappear into toddlers and then into little kids and then into big kids and on and on. The constant disappearing act leaves me off-balance. Think you know that little boy? Wait a few months and a new little boy will be in his place. Like in Maurice Sendakâs weird and spine-tingling picture book: âOutside, Over Thereâ in which the baby was kidnapped by goblins and replaced with an ice baby. Heâs a new boy with brand-new opinions, he prefers a different nickname, his best friend was an enemy yesterday, and he loves the food cooked by his friendâs mother but canât stand it when you serve it. Then, to keep it interesting, wait a few months more and heâs back to the little boy you knew before, sort of.
But many things about childhood are outrageous and confusing. That is probably why it took so long for me to realize that the kids arenât disappearing at all. They are being incorporated, like yeast into bread or in the way the seed incorporates the rain, soil and sun to become an apple. My daughter has been incorporating into herself. My care, meddling and feeding, like soil, sun and rain, are no separate thing but necessary and indivisible.
Iâll pick her up this afternoon. Sheâll learn things I canât even imagine. Perhaps the baby cries because it already knows the lesson of object permanence. There is no such thing.
How to make sure emergency personnel know who to call if you’re injured in an accident.
Every parent or caregiver worries about being able to protect their child, aged parent, or other loved one. If you’re in an accident, how can you let first responders know who to call?
As a trusts & estates attorney, I have the privilege of helping families through every stage of life. Whether it’s a new college grad setting up a basic protective plan or grandparents planning for the next generation – I have been honored to help families through many different situations.
Taking care of your physical safety is fundamental to an estate plan. Here are some tools that I and my clients use:
Use your iPhone’s health app (video link below)
You can add emergency contacts to your iPhone and some android phones, too. This is a great idea because you’re likely to carry your phone with you to most places.
If you have an iPhone, follow these steps to set up your emergency contacts:
There’s an area to manually add Medical Notes. Here’s an example of how you might use this space:
The names and phone numbers in the image are blocked out, you’ll want to make sure to include that information in your notes.
Many android phones have similar health apps.
If you don’t have a Health app on your phone, you can change the lock-screen to display an In Case of Emergency (commonly called “ICE”) contact and phone number. Typically, space is limited on the lock-screen display so, use that space thoughtfully. An example is “ICE Jane Doe (888) 888-5855”.
DocuBank for Emergency Directives
Emergency personnel tell me that if an advance health care directive isn’t available. It doesn’t exist. This means that it’s not enough to have a medical directive in your file at home. It needs to be available to medical professionals in an emergency. This is where DocuBank steps in.
Members send a copy of their advance health care directive to DocuBank to be stored and accessed on-demand in case of an emergency. DocuBank provides a wallet card with a unique number and pin, allergies, medication and emergency contact info to each member. In an emergency, EMTs or other medical professionals can call or go online to retrieve the advance health care directive and get you the help you need right away.
If you’re an estate planning client and you don’t have a DocuBank membership, contact me. You can find more info about DocuBank here.
Create a Basic Estate Plan
A basic estate plan tells your loved ones how to care for you and the people that matter to you. It is the cornerstone of adulting 101. If you don’t have a basic estate plan in place . . . you’re like most people and let’s face it, you’re not happy being average.
Talk to your loved ones about what you want for yourself and each other. The Coda Alliance realized that this can be a very intimidating conversation so they created this set of cards to make it easier.
In my experience, sharing your wishes with your family is an amazing gift. Clients have told me that they felt so completely loved when they realized their parent had made final arrangements. On the other hand, deciding final wishes can be overwhelming and difficult when facing a terminal illness. For this reason, I recommend having this conversation as soon as possible.
If you have resources that I haven’t listed here, I’d love to hear about them. Feel fee to leave them in the comments below or send me a note.
I created this download to offer some ideas about what type of planning is typical for people by age. Most people are complicated and life is . . . interesting. This means that a chart like this should not be relied on to make any decisions.
I hope it does bring awareness and raise questions for you to bring to your own attorney. Only your attorney can tell you what’s best for you.
Starting a new job is an exciting new chapter in your life. Depending on your companyâs onboarding process, there can be a lot of moving parts. You may feel overwhelmed by the introduction and review of the many different types of employee benefits. Not only are there forms to be filled out, they need to be filled out properly to ensure that your financial and estate planning wishes are carried out.
By making the appropriate elections and designations, you can make sure that many of your benefits go to the right people at the right time.
Beneficiary Designations
Beneficiary designation forms are an effective way for you to choose who should receive the death benefit from your employer-provided life insurance policy or the balance of your retirement account if either or both of these benefits are being offered to you as part of your employment. The beneficiary designation forms allow you to name a primary beneficiary and a contingent beneficiary (as backup in case the primary beneficiary is deceased or does not want the money). You have several choices when naming a primary beneficiary. You can choose one person, two people to split the death benefit or account, a charity, or even a trust. In some circumstances, your employerâs plan may require that your spouse be listed as the primary beneficiary of the retirement account or consent to someone else being named as primary beneficiary.
Because the beneficiary designation will override anything written in a will or trust, it is important that you complete this form properly. If you do not fill it out and subsequently die, the account or death benefit will be distributed according to the default rules of the account or policy agreement, which may give the balance to your spouse or heirs, as defined by the plan agreement or applicable state law, or to your estate, which will require your loved ones to go through the costly, time-consuming, and public probate process and could result in adverse tax consequences because of a shorter payout period.
Note that most people find that life insurance provided by an employer is rarely sufficient. For example, the policy usually ends when you leave the job and as you age, your health profile may make it hard for you to find affordable insurance. Thatâs why most financial advisors recommend purchasing life insurance while youâre in good health.
Stock or Other Ownership Interests
If you are being offered company stock or other ownership interests as part of your employment benefits, it is important that you understand what that entails. Experienced financial, tax, and estate planning professionals should be contacted so they can help you understand what you have received. To properly plan, you need to know
the type of interest,
when the interest vests,
whether there any tax obligations or reporting requirements,
what will happen if you leave your employment,
what happens if you die while still employed, and
how you can pass along your interest to your loved ones through your estate plan.
To safeguard the employment benefits you may be offered, a foundational estate plan is key to tying everything together for a successful future.
Foundational Estate Planning
A foundational estate plan can close the gap on making sure you and your loved ones get the most protection for when you need it.
Last will and testament. This document, also known as a will, or a pour-over will if you also have a revocable living trust, can be used to name an executor or personal representative to wind up your affairs, direct what should happen with your money and property, and nominate someone as a guardian for your minor children if you have any. Your family will have to go through probate to receive any money or property controlled by the will.
Revocable living trust. As an alternative to a standalone will, a revocable living trust allows you and your loved ones to avoid the probate process by transferring your money and property to a trust during your lifetime or naming the trust as a beneficiary of your accounts and property. In most cases, you are the trustee and continue to manage the money and property. In addition, you can continue to enjoy the use of the money and property during your lifetime. If you become unable to manage your financial affairs, a successor trustee that you previously selected can step in without court involvement and manage the trust on your behalf and for your benefit. You can also designate what will happen to the trustâs money and property at your death.
Financial power of attorney. This document allows you to choose a trusted person (an agent or attorney-in-fact) to handle your financial matters (sign checks, open a bank account, etc.). In this document, you can specify the scope of the agentâs authority and when the agent can act. Without this document, a court will need to appoint someone if you need someone to handle a financial matter on your behalf. This can take time and money that may not be available in the midst of a crisis.
Medical power of attorney. This document allows you to appoint a trusted person as your decision maker to communicate or make healthcare decisions on your behalf if you cannot do so. Absent this designation, the court may be required to name someone to make these decisions for you, costing your loved ones time, money, and privacy.
Advance Health Care Directive. This document, known by either name depending on your state, allows you to convey your wishes regarding end-of-life decisions. Properly documenting your wishes can make them easier to carry out and reduce tensions brought on by uncertainty.
HIPAA authorization form. A Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) form allows you to grant specific individuals access to your medical information (e.g., to get a status update on your condition or receive test results) without giving those individuals the authority to make decisions on your behalf. Sometimes having information can help reduce tensions among the parties involved because everyone has access to the same information even if only one party has the authority to make any decisions.
Joining a new company is an exciting adventure. In addition to the human resources representative at your new company, we are here to help you protect the legacy you are in the process of building by creating a proper estate plan.
More often than ever couples are looking to plan for their futures with each other but without marriage.
This article addresses some of the options that unmarried couples have when planningâs transitions.
As with all relationships there are benefits and drawbacks to âmaking it official.â Depending on the value of your money and property, your desired level of protection from your partnerâs creditors, and other factors unique to your situation, one or more of these strategies may be beneficial.
“Love is a two-way street constantly under construction.” â Carroll Bryant
A word of caution: regardless of what methods you use, you must work with an experienced estate planning attorney. While do-it-yourself options may be cheaper, small, seemingly inconsequential decisions can sometimes create more problems than they solve, and the problems can be expensive to remedy. In California, we see this often with transfers of real estate between unmarried people when property tax increase exponentially.
Add Your Partner as a Joint Owner on an Account or Piece of Property
Making your partner a joint owner isone of the easiest ways to give your partner immediate access to and control over an account or property. As long as the account or property is owned jointly with the right of survivorship, your partner will automatically become the sole owner upon your death with no involvement by the probate court.
This option has its shortcomings. Because your partner will become the sole owner at your death, your partner, not you, gets to choose what will happen to the account or property upon their death. You have to trust that your partner will make a decision you would have supported. In addition, once your partner becomes a joint owner of the account or property, your partnerâs debts become your problem. Should your partner become subject to a creditorâs claim or lawsuit, the creditors could seize your jointly owned account or property to satisfy any outstanding judgment. Finally, if you and your partner break up, removing your partnerâs name from your accounts or property could be problematic and lead to costly and emotional litigation if your partner is unwilling to cooperate.
Name Your Partner as the Beneficiary of a Retirement Account or Life Insurance Policy
Most retirement accounts and life insurance policies have beneficiary designation forms that allow you to dictate who will receive your retirement account balance or the death benefit when you die. In many cases, the instructions ask you to name a primary beneficiary and a contingent beneficiary (as backup in case the primary beneficiary is deceased or does not want the money). Adding your partner as a beneficiary is another easy solution to get money to your partner at your death without jeopardizing your ability to control the account or policy during your lifetime.
On the other hand, should your partner be sued, that money could be available to satisfy any judgments against your partner. Any money remaining when your partner dies goes to your partnerâs heirs, not yours. This also doesnât work if you want to make sure your partner is cared for since you wonât be able to control how the money will be spent. Your partner could bet it all on the 49ers to win the SuperBowl and take all their friends a fancy dinner at French Laundry.
Name Your Partner as the Pay-on-Death or Transfer-on-Death Beneficiary of an Account
Naming your partner as the pay-on-death (POD) or transfer-on-death (TOD) beneficiary of an account has the same pitfalls as naming them on a beneficiary designation form. Although the POD or TOD option allows you to maintain control of the account during your lifetime after the account has been transferred or the funds paid to your partner at your death, the account or money will become your partnerâs. The money then becomes subject to any creditors or judgments your partner may face, it can be spent on frivolous items, and your partner gets to decide what happens to any remaining amounts.
Another downside of the POD or TOD option is that your partner will have access to the money in these accounts only upon your death. Should you become incapacitated (unable to make your decisions), the accounts would still be deemed yours and your partner could not access the funds, absent additional estate planning measures.
Name Your Partner as a Beneficiary in Your Last Will and Testament
A Last Will and Testament allows you to specify what money and property (owned solely in you and not automatically passing to a surviving joint owner or beneficiary) your partner will receive and how your partner will receive it (for example, as a lump sum or as installments over time).
If you choose to leave money or property to your partner, these items are vulnerable to the risks mentioned above, because your partner owns them outright. However, with a will, we can create a testamentary trust to provide extra protection for the money and property you leave to your partner. You must remember, however, that if you use a will, your partner will have to go through the probate process to get the money and property at your death and the probate process could be under court supervision until your partner receives the final amount. In addition, a will is effective only at your death. It will not provide any instructions or benefits to your partner if you become incapacitated.
Name Your Partner as a Beneficiary of Your Revocable Living Trust
A revocable living trust (RLT) is a trust you create during your lifetime that can be changed until your incapacity or death. While you are alive and can make decisions for yourself, you are both the current trustee (the person or entity who manages, invests, and hands out the money and property) and the current beneficiary (allowing you to continue enjoying the money and property during your lifetime). In the trust agreement, you determine who manages the trust and who receives the benefit of the money and property during your lifetime and at your death. You can specify how your partner should be financially provided for during any period of your incapacity, what accounts or property your partner will receive, and when and how your partner will receive the money and property at your death. Under a carefully drafted RLT, the accounts or property can be used to support your partner after your death and even while you are alive and unable to manage your affairs. Also, anything you want your partner to receive can be protected from your partnerâs creditors or judgments and from your partnerâs spending the money or selling the property to buy extravagant items. The accounts and property owned by the trust will avoid probate, a significant benefit that allows you to keep your private matters out of court and away from prying eyes.
Note, however, that if, after your death, your trust owns any accounts that generate income that is not given to the beneficiaries, the trust will be taxed on the income, usually at a higher rate than what an individual would pay on the same income. Also, the longer the trust exists, the longer it needs to be managed, so there could be ongoing fees associated with the trust such as tax preparation, investment, and management fees, depending on who is the trustee.
We Are Here to Help
As you can see, there are several different ways to provide for your partner during your incapacity or when you die. We are here to help you craft a plan that addresses your concerns and help you ensure that your partner is taken care of during all phases of life. Call us today to schedule your phone or video consultation.
Genealogy has long fascinated many people, and it continues to be studied by those who are interested in discovering who they descended from and what those family members were like. Many of us have gazed at black and white or sepia-tone photos of ancestors whose names we donât know and wondered about their lives, joys, trials, and accomplishments. Fortunately, today, there are many resources making it much easier to discover information about prior generations of our families.
Celebrate National Genealogy Day this month by delving into the past to find out more about your family members, but also by taking steps to leave behind a legacy for your own present and future family members. By creating an estate plan, you can benefit future generations, not only monetarily, but also by sharing important values and life lessons.
Investigate the Past
Talk to members of the older generation. If you have older relatives still living, take advantage of their knowledge to gain more information not only about their lives, but also about your family tree and the individuals comprising it. You can ask them about how important historical events impacted them and other family members, where they grew up, stories about other family members, the occupations of family members, and other facets of their lives.
Do research. Online services are available that enable you to do research for a fee, but you may also be able to find some information using the libraries of local genealogical societies, genealogical resources in local public libraries, or genealogy databases available at the U.S. Library of Congress. Some companies may even enable you to identify other people to whom you may be related, as well as the cultures and migration paths of your ancestors, by analyzing a sample of your DNA.
Using these tools, you can find out a lot about your family and geographical roots. But you can also get inspired to leave something behind for your own descendants.
Have an Impact on the Future
Leave monetary gifts. Most parents and grandparents want to leave an inheritance for their family members. You can draft a will to transfer the money and property you have worked hard to accumulate to your loved ones, but a simple will alone is often not the best estate planning tool. If you leave outright gifts to your children and grandchildren, there is no guarantee that it will be spent wisely and it can be taken by beneficiariesâ creditors to satisfy claims. In addition, the money and property transferred using a will has to go through probate proceedings, which can be lengthy and expensive, and are open to the public. If you want to ensure that your money and property are available to benefit your family over the long term without the hassle of probate, there are other estate planning tools you can use.
You can make life easier not only for your children but potentially also for your grandchildren by creating a trust, either during your lifetime or that will become effective upon your death, naming them as beneficiaries. When you form and fund a trust, it can hold money and property for the benefit of specific people, and certain types of trusts will protect it from future legal claims arising from lawsuits, creditorsâ claims, or divorcing spouses. In addition, you can include terms designed to ensure the funds held in the trust are sustainable by specifying how and when money should be distributed to your beneficiaries. You could decide to have it transferred as a lump sum upon your death, have portions of it distributed when the beneficiaries reach certain ages, or state that it should be distributed for specific purposes, such as expenses for their health, education, support, and welfare. In addition, you can have a positive impact on the lives of your children and grandchildren by setting aside funds to help them with expenditures associated with certain important life events, i.e., a wedding, college tuition, a down payment on a house, or funding for a new business.
Leave gifts reflecting your values.
Not all wealth is in the form of money and property. Over a lifetime, an individual accumulates a wealth of knowledge, life lessons, values, and experiences that can be shared with later generations. Two great ways you can communicate your values, life experiences, and knowledge are creating an ethical will and leaving instructions for your funeral service.
Ethical will. An ethical will, sometimes called a legacy letter, is not a binding legal document. Rather, it is simply a letterâor even a video recordingâin which you can communicate any important values, sentiments, or life lessons that you think will benefit your family members and descendants. Your ethical will can be one of the most meaningful parts of your estate plan, and it can become a part of your family history that will be cherished by future family members who may have no other opportunity to know you or benefit from the wisdom you have gained over a lifetime.
Funeral or memorial service. Although no one enjoys thinking about their own funeral, one of the most thoughtful acts you can do for your loved ones is to make arrangements in advance for your own funeral service. It is also a means to ensure that your service includes elements reflecting values or religious convictions that you want to communicate and pass on to your family members and loved ones. In your arrangements, you can ask the officiate to include scripture verses, songs, or stories that convey principles that you would like your children and grandchildren to heed.
Care for Your FamilyâPast and Future
This month, you can celebrate National Genealogy Day by spending a little time investigating your familyâs roots by researching genealogical records. But an even more important investment of your time can be made by creating an estate plan designed to provide both a monetary and spiritual inheritance that will enhance your family membersâ future. Call us today to schedule a meeting so we can help you create an estate plan enabling you to pass on all aspects of your wealth.
Maintaining your estate plan can feel overwhelming when faced with all the changes life can bring. Calling your attorney may not be your first instinct when youâre faced with a significant shift in income, investments, or employment, but consulting with us is a wise way to ensure your legal health is always maintained. Read on for five events that should capture your attention and prompt you to reach out to us for some personalized advice.
Youâve opened a new retirement account or established a new retirement plan.
As we all know, planning for oneâs retirement is crucial. The peace of mind provided by a solid retirement plan is irreplaceable. The way you and your financial advisors choose to structure your retirement plan and invest your retirement assets will vary, as they are designed to meet your particular needs, wants, and goals. Keep in mind that if you open a new account, your estate plan will need to be reviewed and possibly updated as well. A new taxable investment account may need to be âfundedâ into your trust. If youâve set up or started contributing to a tax-deferred account, such as a 401(k), IRA, Roth IRA, employee stock ownership plan, or another type of retirement plan, contact us about your estate plan, too, since we want to be certain that your beneficiary designation is exactly what you intend.
Youâve started a new job.
Congratulations! A new professional opportunity is exciting, and it is accompanied by plenty of financial change. As weâve seen above, taking a new retirement plan or account into consideration is quite important, and a new company often means a new account. You may also have new employer-sponsored life insurance, so itâs important to seek our help to verify that your life insurance beneficiaries remain up to date.
Youâve kept the same job.
Even if this year finds you in the same job as last, open enrollment can begin when you have a life change, for example, the birth of a child, marriage or divorce. Make sure you update or verify your life insurance and retirement plan beneficiaries. We can help ensure that everything is as it should be.
You have teenaged children.
Your childâs 18th birthday is not only a rite of passage but also a significant change in legal status and planning needs. Be sure to schedule a meeting with us to learn what you and your teen need to do as your teen becomes an adult.
You started a business.
Whether youâve fully jumped in or kept your day job, starting a business is a bold step! Itâs in your best interest to take precautions to ensure your business is fully protected. In addition to the business entity issues, tax planning, and growing your business, there are estate planning implications with a new business. We can help you coordinate your new business with your estate plan.
As always, I am here for you if you have questions about the health of your estate and how it is affected by the big changes in your life. Together, we can develop or enhance your estate plan to meet your goals and secure your familyâs future. Feel free to schedule a call.
Most people understand that having some sort of an estate plan is a good thing. However, many of us do not take the first steps to get that estate plan in place because we do not understand the nuances between a will and trust â and dying without either.
Here is what will generally happen if you die, intestate (without a will or trust), with a will, and with a revocable living trust (weâll just call it a âtrustâ from here on).
Hereâs an example, it assumes that you have two children, but arenât married. This is a common scenario with divorced people or on the death of the second spouse:
Intestate. If you die intestate, your accounts and property will go through probate and all the world will know what you owned, what you owed, and who got what. Your mortgage company, car loan company, and credit card companies will all seek payment on balances you owed at the time of your death.
Keep in mind that since your death has been published to alert valid creditors, it is common for predators (fake creditors) to contact your family and demand for payment for debts you donât even owe.
After that, state law will decide who gets what and when.
For example, if your only heirs are your two children and you have not provided any instructions, state law will mandate divvying up proceeds equally.
Your older child will get their share immediately if they have attained adulthood (18 or 21 years, depending on state law).
But, the court will appoint a guardian to manage the money for your minor child until that child becomes an adult.
Shockingly, that guardian can charge a lot of money for their services and be a total stranger.
If you die without a valid will, the court, not you, will decide who raises your minor child.
The bottom line? Dying intestate allows state law and the court to make all the decisions on your behalf â regardless of what your intent might have been. Publicity is guaranteed.
Will. If you die with a valid will, your accounts and property will still go through the probate process. However, after creditors have been paid, the remaining accounts and property will go to whom you have named in your will.
So, if you want to leave money to your children and name a guardian for the minor, the court will usually abide by your wishes.
The same holds true if you specified that you wanted to give money to a charity, your Aunt Betty, or your neighbor.
Keep in mind that predatory creditors are still an issue as your death has been publicized. Even with a will, probate is still a public process.
The bottom line? While a court oversees the process, having a will allows you to tell the court exactly how you want your affairs to be handled. But, a public probate is still guaranteed.
Trust. If you have created a trust, you have taken control of your estate plan and your accounts and property. Accounts and property owned by the trust are not subject to the probate process and one of the most important benefits of a trust is that the details and process of transferring accounts and property to the intended individuals is private.
In the trust, you will have named a trusted individual (trustee) to manage your affairs with specific instructions on how your accounts and property should be dispersed and when.
One word of caution â a trust must be properly funded in order to bypass probate.
Funding means that ownership of your accounts and property has been changed from your name individually to the name of your trust.
Think of your trust as a bushel basket. You must put the apples into the basket just like you must put your accounts and property into the trust for either to have real value.
You do still need a will (pour-over will) to get any accounts or property inadvertently or intentionally left out of your trust into the name of the trust. You will also still need a will to name guardians for a minor child.
The bottom line? A trust allows you to maintain control of your accounts and property through your chosen trustee, avoid probate, and leave specific instructions so that your children are taken care of â without receiving a lump sum of money at an age where they are more likely to squander it or have it seized from them.
Do not let the will versus trust controversy slow you down. Call the office today; we will put together an estate plan that works for you and your loved ones.
NOTE: As always, the information on this website is for general information and entertainment only. Do not rely on this information to take a course of action or refrain from taking action – hire a lawyer.
California Proposition 19, Changes Certain Property Tax Rules. Legislative Constitutional Amendment. (2020)
Summary: The passage of Proposition 19 has generated a number of estate planning issues. For example, the changes could affect pre-existing trusts, such as qualified personal residence trusts, which are typically established with the intent of allowing parents to continue to live in the home while passing ownership on to their children. Once Proposition 19 takes effect, the property will be reassessed unless the children are also using it as their primary residenceâand even if they are using it as their primary residence, there is a cap of $1 million on the exclusion. Thus, strategies designed to mitigate unfavorable results should be effectuated without delay. However, the benefits of making a lifetime transfer of the property must be weighed against those of a transfer at death, which would enable the children to have a stepped-up basis in the property. Gift and estate tax considerations may also come into play.
Discussion: Proposition 19, a California ballot measure, modifies Proposition 13 (which limits increases of real property tax to two percent per year unless reassessed due to sale or transfer) and Proposition 58 (which allows property owners to transfer their primary residence to their children at the preferential property tax assessment and up to $1 million of assessed value of other real property, with a later proposition extending the benefit to qualifying grandchildren).
Under Proposition 19, only a primary residence, not other real property, can be transferred to children or qualifying grandchildren at the preferential assessed value. Further, the preferential assessed value is only available if the children or qualifying grandchildren will use the home as their primary residence and to the extent that the fair market value of the residence does not exceed the assessed value by more than $1 million. This part of Proposition 19 takes effect on February 16, 2021 (note that February 15 is Presidentâs Day, when recorderâs offices will be closed).
Some examples provide additional clarity regarding the effect of Proposition 19:
Under current law: Parents seek to give their home and a rental property to their child. The home has a taxable value of $2 million with a property tax bill of $22,000. Today, the home has appreciated, and the value is now $4 million, which means it has increased by $2 million. If the parents gift the home to their child, the taxable value remains $2 million, and the child receives the benefit of continuing to pay only $22,000 on the assessed value (with modest annual increases). The rental property has a taxable value of $500,000, but its FMV is $1 million, with a property tax bill of $5,500. The parents could gift the rental property to their child, and the taxable value of the property would also remain the same at $5,500.
Under Prop 19: Using the same examples, and assuming the child uses the home as the childâs principal residence, only the first $1 million of increased value in the home is exempt. However, the home has increased in value by $2 million, resulting in only $1 million of the increase being excluded from reassessment, or $3 million of assessed value. This would result in a new property tax bill to the child of $33,000. Since there is no longer an exemption for non-principal residences, the rental property is reassessed to FMV of $1 million, resulting in a tax bill to the child of $11,000. Between the two properties, this is a net increase in annual property taxes of $16,500 over the pre-Prop 19 parent-child exclusion.
*1.1% is used for calculating tax bill on taxable value
Proposition 19 also provides benefits for certain homeowners. Under current law, homeowners over fifty-five years old and certain disabled individuals can transfer the taxable value from their current home to a new residence in the same county if the value of the new home is less than or equal to the value of their old home. Proposition 19 allows victims of wildfires and other natural disasters, regardless of their age or disability, to transfer their taxable value to a new home. In addition, homeowners within the preferred classes are no longer limited to purchasing a new home in the same county but can relocate anywhere in the state of California. Also, the value of the new home can be greater than the value of the previous oneâthough the increase in value must be added to the old homeâs transferred assessed value. This change will become effective on April 1, 2021.
When I moved out of my hometown to go to law school, my grandmother would send me packages of homemade tortillas and chocolate chip cookies. She sent these little tastes of home, not because there were no Mexican grandmothers making tortillas in my new town, but as a way to remind me of her love.
She was so proud of me for daring to reach for my dreams and homemade tortillas were one of her ways to support me. She also tried matchmaking. Anytime I took her to a routine doctorâs visit or even to the hospital in an emergency, âHi doctor, yes Iâm having trouble breathing. Are you married? No? Good, this is my granddaughter, sheâs going to be a lawyer.â But thatâs another story.
When I meet with families about how to distribute their estate after they pass away, they often want to make similar âI love youâ gifts. Gifts of tortillas haven’t come up, instead its usually cash gifts to friends or loved ones. Sometimes these are very small gifts but they represent big love. This usually comes up when we are designing a trust – the most popular way to pass property in California. Note: If you live in California and donât have revocable living trust and you have children or own your own home, you probably need a trust.
One of the underlying themes with cash or care packages of tortillas and chocolate chip cookies, is that we equate these gifts with love. Take a scenario of a mother who leaves her son $1,000,000 and her daughter $1,000. Many people would ask why only $1,000 to the daughter? When parents do things like this is can be confusing and hurtful to their children. Even though parents usually have some logical reason, it can feel like a slap in the face to the daughter receiving only a percentage of what brother received. Consider also, what will become of the relationship between the son and daughter? Did we make the holidays tense and uncomfortable? Have we torn an emotional gash that will estrange the children from each other for the rest of their lives? We must always consider the impact of our gifting.
In estate planning parlance gifts of money made in a Will or Trust are called âgeneral giftsâ and they are often problematic. So much so that Californiaâs preeminent practice guide warns that these gifts âcan distort the settlor’s dispositive plan, the trust drafter should counsel sparing use of them.â
What makes these gifts of cash so problematic?
A general gift is paid first.
Consider a father with a net worth of $100,000.
He wants his daughter to inherit most of his wealth but also wants to make sure his best fishing pal is remembered with a gift of $10,000.
If father dies right after signing his trust, the fishing buddy would get a cash gift of $10,000 and his daughter would inherit everything else, $90,000. But it also almost never happens this way.
Most commonly, father goes on his merry way, happy that heâs taken care of his daughter and made a nice gift to his fishing buddy.
Years later, father has had some medical issues and spent a large amount of his savings on his medical care.
When he passes away, father’s estate is only worth $11,000. The general gift is paid first so his fishing buddy gets a $10,000 and his daughter inherits the remainder, just $1,000. Was this father’s intent? What will the daughter think? Remember, when dealing with the death of a loved one, money equals love.
Consider that even if the trust value is at least $100k when dad dies, all the assets might not be held in cash. For example, dad could own a $100K a home intending that daughter inherit it when he dies. On his death, the trustee is require to make the general gift first so the house is sole to pay the $10,000 gift to the fishing buddy. Again, not the outcome dad would have wanted.
Your Trust is Mostly Private Unless Itâs Not
One of the benefits of a trust is that it is a private document. Unlike a Will, it is not filed in a courthouse for the world to read. This is a real benefit because bad guys and fraudsters are staying up nights to separate your heirs from your money.
I am not a fan of hiding things unless there is a good reason to do so. Justice Brennan said âsunlight is the best disinfectantâ and I often refer to that adage when trying to decide the best way to make a gift. Secrets among family members have a habit of causing trouble. However, there are times and good reasons for keeping things private.
Under California law, when you pass away certain people have a right to demand to see a copy of the trust. Typically, those people include your heirs at law (people who would have inherited if you did not have a Will or Trust) and those people named in your trust. Â
If you leave dramatically different general gifts in your trust it can cause hurt feelings, driving people to fight and even litigate over what they thought they should have inherited. Do you want your niece to know how much you gave to her cousin? If not, better to make a gift in another way.
Your Gift May Not Be So Great After All
When I graduated from college with a degree in accounting my first job at prestigious tech company paid $15 per hour plus benefits. I happy with that. Now, over 20 years later, that is barely minimum wage in my town.
Consider that your very generous gift of $25K today might be spare change in 20 years and not have the impact you intended.
So, is there a better alternative than a general gift in a trust?
I think so. Here are some alternatives to consider:
Give a percent of your estate.
In our first example, dad could have divided his estate in percentages: 10% to his buddy and 90% daughter. When dad passed away with %11,000, the buddy would have inherited $1,100 and daughter $8,900 â which was dadâs likely intent.
Use life insurance
A life insurance policy pays out a benefit to your beneficiaries when you die. There are some drawbacks to life insurance, for example if you forget to pay the premium or fail to update beneficiary designations.
Name your intended heir as pay on death beneficiary of a bank account, brokerage account, IRA, etc.
Using bank accounts like this are called âwill substitutesâ and they have their own set of risks and drawbacks. For example, my grandfather set up bank accounts naming my sister and I as pay on death beneficiaries. At some point, the accounts were either closed or emptied and when he died there was nothing for us. We were left to wonder did he intentionally disinherit us? Was he defrauded by a caregiver? Did he simply need the money during the end of his life? We will never know.
There are other issues with these will substitutes but there is a time and place for them.
Give the money now
A huge benefit of making a gift today is that you get the satisfaction of seeing someone really appreciate your gift because you are alive, after all. A drawback is that if you need the money for yourself later on, you wonât have it anymore. Also, some people feel that a gift made in a Will or Trust is more impactful than a lifetime gift. If you choose to do this, keep track of these gifts and keep your estate planning attorney and CPA informed.
Everyoneâs circumstances are different and if your attorney suggests making general gifts thatâs likely the best arrangement for you in your current circumstances.
There are certainly other considerations that I have not mentioned here with transferring cash and property. What are some creative ideas you have for making gifts of cash after you pass away?
Remember that everything you read on this website is for general information and entertainment purposes only. Do not take action or fail to act based on anything you read on this site. If anything you read on this website raises questions or concerns for you, take all that to your attorney so that you can get advice that is appropriate for you.